Suprema: Authentic Italian Dining Experience in Rutherford, NJ

Food is delicious! Busy, modern, small Italian restaurant. 4 stars because the wait time for the food to come out is kinda long (went twice on weekday dinner and both times we waited 40+ min for our entrees), and it can be a bit too crowded and noisy. I must say their Arancini is so good.

I’m in loveeeeeeeeeeee with my Carbonara here!! The weather was so perfect to sit outside and I like it, the food was so good and the service was excellent. Will be back to try the rest on the menu.

Hello my Foodies! So I was at this place for my friends Birthday. They have real food meaning made fresh and organic. I could tell it tasted so Different from the processed food I am used to I guess. Everything tasted fresh, and it did take me a minute to get into this food, but after a bit, I really did like my pasta. The chocolate dessert we got after was absolutely delicious. The pasta I had tasted great the next day. Also, that Steaz drink was delicious! Order it! Our server was excellent and took great care of our party. I did hear another server tell a young couple who came in around 8pm that they couldn't seat them because the kitchen closed at 730pm. I thought that was kinda early, especially since their operating hours say until 9 pm. But maybe because it was a Wednesday? I'm not sure. They don't have parking so you need to find parking in the street, but it was really good food. I recommend checking this place out.

You can’t go wrong with this small authentic BYOB —- Italian restaurant in Rutherford, NJ. The food was fresh and I love food made to order. You can tell that it wasn’t made in advance which is a huge advantage over other restaurants when eating out. Service was great but the restaurant is a little bit loud because you can hear all of the conversation happening around you. Definitely give this place a try this summer because I’ll be going back.

My husband and I had lunch at Suprema with our three kids, and it was absolutely fantastic! The food was top-notch from start to finish—every dish, from the appetizers to dessert, was outstanding. Even our picky eaters left happy! The vibe is super cute, making it perfect for a relaxed yet elevated meal. The service was excellent—attentive and friendly. We highly recommend Suprema and can’t wait to return for dinner!

This place is absolutely gorgeous! Very clean and the food was delicious. I do not remember the name of the plates, but for those who love a visual here you go! My kids had the spaghetti and meat ball and of course I had to take a bite! Lol Oh one thing I can remember the muscles if you love muscles you will love the ones at Suprema! Btw for those who are into organic Meals Suprema is it!

any place that gives an aioli type sauce with the calamari is good in my book, rib ragú was really good n my girl got the bolognese lasagna, both rly good. The staff is very nice even offered to take a photo of us for our anniversary :) also too the mountain valley water probably the best water I’ve had

BYOB! Went for a birthday celebration, ten plus table. Off-street meter parking only, so parking can be a hassle. Reservations were made so seated immediately. Appetizers were tasteful and came on time. Im always skeptical with Italian restaurants having tried so many, but interesting enough the dish my wife and I selected were not heavy in the sauce. I had no acid reflux at night which even solidified this review. Would come back again! APPROVED!