Suprema Menu
Welcome to Suprema, an intimate Italian gem nestled in Rutherford, NJ. This bustling eatery is celebrated for its authentic dishes crafted from fresh, organic ingredients. From delightful starters like the crowd-favorite Arancini to the comforting richness of Carbonara, each dish showcases the culinary expertise of a dedicated kitchen team.
Despite occasional wait times and a lively atmosphere, diners rave about the remarkable flavors and the personal touch in every meal. Olivia notes the delicious food although mentioning the 40-minute wait, while Paulina highlights a family-friendly vibe perfect for any occasion. The stress or noise fades as each morsel transports you to Italy's heart.
Whether you're savoring a plate of pasta al dente or indulging in mouthwatering desserts, Suprema promises a culinary experience that embraces tradition and quality. Don’t miss out on this authentic BYOB haven!
Food - Salads
Caesar Salad
With organic baby romaine lettuce, cage free egg, crispy pancetta, golden ciabatta croutons and shaved Reggiano parmesan cheese with caesar dressing.
Artichoke Salad
With organic mixed baby greens, shaved parmesan cheese, and Sicilian pistachios with extra virgin olive oil, fresh lemon juice, and cracked pepper.
Chicken Milanese Salad
With bell and Evans chicken cutlet, organic arugula, marinated grape tomatoes, Parmigiano Reggiano, aged balsamic vinegar, and extra virgin olive.
Quinoa Salad
organic mixed greens, quinoa, goat cheese, cherry tomatoes, avocado, almonds, , champagne vinaigrette
Apple And Blue Cheese Salad
organic mixed greens, pink lady apples, hazelnuts, gorgonzola, grapes, white balsamic
Suprema Green Salad
organic mixed greens, shaved carrots, cucumbers, heirlooms, shallots, avocado, champagne vinaigrette
Toscana
balsamic marinated eggplant, roasted red peppers, grilled zucchini, freseh mozzarella, basil pesto
Turkey
roasted turkey, avocado, backyard tomatoes, arugula, house made pesto mayo, sliced potato onion bread
Chicken
Bell and Evans breaded chicken cutlet, mozzarella, arugula, and fresh tomato with a balsamic vinaigrette.
Prosciutto
imported prosciutto, mozzarella, sweet sun dried peppers, basil, extra virgin olive oil, balsamic
Roast Beef
house cooked roast beef, mozzarella cheese, rich brown gravy
Grilled Chicken BLT
Grilled Chicken, maple bacon, greens, marinated tomatoes pesto mayo, sliced panella
Waldorf Chicken
hand pulled chicken breast, grapes, apples, carrots, golden raisins, honey djonnaise dressing, butter lettuce, toasted sourdough
Sausage
local fennel sausage, broccoli rabe, burrata, caramelized onions, balsamic reduction
Chicken Parm Sandwich
crispy bell and evans boneless breast, mozzarella cheese with your choice of marinara or vodka sauce
Eggplant Parmigiana Sandwich
fried eggplant, mozzarella cheese, basil, pecorino cheese, with your choice of marinara or vodka sauce
Meatball Parmigiana
grass fed beef meatballs, mozzarella cheese, basil, with your choice of marinara or vodka sace
Food - Sandwiches
Food - Appetizers
Rice Balls
Creamy risotto, mozzarella, tomato and basil.
Meatballs With Ricotta
Grass fed beef, homemade breadcrumbs, grated pecorino, garlic & herbs with san marzano plum tomatoes.
Burrata Caprese
imported burrata, heirloom tomatoes, basil pesto, toasted ciabatta, aged balsamic ans extra virgin olive oil
Cheesy Garlic Bread
housemade whipped ricotta, sea salt focaccia, hot honey
Mozzarella Sticks
homemade mozzarella, grated pecorino, breadcrumbs, pomodoro
Lemon And Garlic Shrimp
gulf shrimp, lemon and garlic butter sauce
Fried Calamari
Whipped Ricotta Bruschetta Dip
fresh local ricotta, roma tomatoes, basil, extra virgin olive oil, toasted crostini
Apple Blue Cheese App
Spagehtti Pomodoro
guitar string shaped pasta, san marzano tomatoes and cherry tomatoes, fresh garlic, extra virgin, basil leaves
Spaghetti Carbonara
cage free eggs, pancetta, pecorino, cracked pepper
Rigatoni Vodka
San marzano tomatoes, vodka, cream, basil
Bucatini With Artichoke And Pistachio
short cut pasta, broccoli rabe, fennel pork sausage, garlic, extra virgin, grated cheese
Tagliatelle Beef Rib Ragu
long ribbon pasta, slow simmered beef and pork ribs, bone broth, san marzano
Shrimp Arrabiata
spaghetti chitarra, wild caught shrimp, spicy calabrian chili paste, pomodoro, extra virgin olive oil , basil leaves
Casarecci Sausage & BR
Food - Pasta
Food - Desserts
Tiramisu
mascarpone, eggs, espresso, araretto, sponge cake cookie and shaved chocolate
Chocolate Layer Cake
rich valrhona chocolate, chocolate buttercream
Affogato
NY Cheesecake
Carrot Cake
Gelato 1 Scoop
Gelato 2 Scoops
Gelato 3 Scoops
One Rice Ball
Fries
One Cutlet
Hot Chocolate
Side Of Bread
Truffle Fries
Side Broccoli Rabe
Side Long Hots
Side Spinach
Side Roasted Potatoes
Food - Misc
Food - Kids Menu
Kids Pasta
Kids Grilled Chicken/French Fries
Kids Chicken Cutlet/French Fries
Kids Riceballs/French Fries
Kids Meatballs/French Fries
Kids Mozzarella Sticks/French Fries
Artichoke Oreganata
artichoke hearts, pecorino, garlic and herbed breadcrumbs topped with white wine and lemon
The Drunken Veggie Sandwich
fried eggplant, ricotta cheese, melted fresh mozzarella, sauteed spinach, vodka sauce.
Bucatini With White Clam Sauce
fresh little neck clams tossed in garlic white wine, lemon and topped with crispy herb breadcrumbs and parsley
Pistachio Crusted Cod
pistachio crusted cod with lemon butter sauce over potato puree and sauteed spinach
Samoa Cake
Italian Rainbow Cookie Cake
Food - Specials
Salads
Caesar Salad
With organic baby romaine lettuce, cage free egg, crispy pancetta, golden ciabatta croutons and shaved Reggiano parmesan cheese with caesar dressing.
Artichoke Salad
With organic mixed baby greens, shaved parmesan cheese, and Sicilian pistachios with extra virgin olive oil, fresh lemon juice, and cracked pepper.
Chicken Milanese Salad
With bell and Evans chicken cutlet, organic arugula, marinated grape tomatoes, Parmigiano Reggiano, aged balsamic vinegar, and extra virgin olive.
Quinoa Salad
organic mixed greens, quinoa, goat cheese, cherry tomatoes, avocado, almonds, , champagne vinaigrette
Apple And Blue Cheese Salad
organic mixed greens, pink lady apples, hazelnuts, gorgonzola, grapes, white balsamic
Suprema Green Salad
organic mixed greens, shaved carrots, cucumbers, heirlooms, shallots, avocado, champagne vinaigrette
Toscana
balsamic marinated eggplant, roasted red peppers, grilled zucchini, freseh mozzarella, basil pesto
Turkey
roasted turkey, avocado, backyard tomatoes, arugula, house made pesto mayo, sliced potato onion bread
Chicken
Bell and Evans breaded chicken cutlet, mozzarella, arugula, and fresh tomato with a balsamic vinaigrette.
Prosciutto
imported prosciutto, mozzarella, sweet sun dried peppers, basil, extra virgin olive oil, balsamic
Roast Beef
house cooked roast beef, mozzarella cheese, rich brown gravy
Grilled Chicken BLT
Grilled Chicken, maple bacon, greens, marinated tomatoes pesto mayo, sliced panella
Waldorf Chicken
hand pulled chicken breast, grapes, apples, carrots, golden raisins, honey djonnaise dressing, butter lettuce, toasted sourdough
Sausage
local fennel sausage, broccoli rabe, burrata, caramelized onions, balsamic reduction
Chicken Parm Sandwich
crispy bell and evans boneless breast, mozzarella cheese with your choice of marinara or vodka sauce
Eggplant Parmigiana Sandwich
fried eggplant, mozzarella cheese, basil, pecorino cheese, with your choice of marinara or vodka sauce
Meatball Parmigiana
grass fed beef meatballs, mozzarella cheese, basil, with your choice of marinara or vodka sace
Sandwiches
Appetizers
Rice Balls
Creamy risotto, mozzarella, tomato and basil.
Meatballs With Ricotta
Grass fed beef, homemade breadcrumbs, grated pecorino, garlic & herbs with san marzano plum tomatoes.
Burrata Caprese
imported burrata, heirloom tomatoes, basil pesto, toasted ciabatta, aged balsamic ans extra virgin olive oil
Cheesy Garlic Bread
housemade whipped ricotta, sea salt focaccia, hot honey
Mozzarella Sticks
homemade mozzarella, grated pecorino, breadcrumbs, pomodoro
Lemon And Garlic Shrimp
gulf shrimp, lemon and garlic butter sauce
Fried Calamari
Whipped Ricotta Bruschetta Dip
fresh local ricotta, roma tomatoes, basil, extra virgin olive oil, toasted crostini
Apple Blue Cheese App
Spagehtti Pomodoro
guitar string shaped pasta, san marzano tomatoes and cherry tomatoes, fresh garlic, extra virgin, basil leaves
Spaghetti Carbonara
cage free eggs, pancetta, pecorino, cracked pepper
Rigatoni Vodka
San marzano tomatoes, vodka, cream, basil
Bucatini With Artichoke And Pistachio
short cut pasta, broccoli rabe, fennel pork sausage, garlic, extra virgin, grated cheese
Tagliatelle Beef Rib Ragu
long ribbon pasta, slow simmered beef and pork ribs, bone broth, san marzano
Shrimp Arrabiata
spaghetti chitarra, wild caught shrimp, spicy calabrian chili paste, pomodoro, extra virgin olive oil , basil leaves
Casarecci Sausage & BR
Pasta
Desserts
Tiramisu
mascarpone, eggs, espresso, araretto, sponge cake cookie and shaved chocolate
Chocolate Layer Cake
rich valrhona chocolate, chocolate buttercream
Affogato
NY Cheesecake
Carrot Cake
Gelato 1 Scoop
Gelato 2 Scoops
Gelato 3 Scoops
One Rice Ball
Fries
One Cutlet
Hot Chocolate
Side Of Bread
Truffle Fries
Side Broccoli Rabe
Side Long Hots
Side Spinach
Side Roasted Potatoes
Misc
Kids Menu
Kids Pasta
Kids Grilled Chicken/French Fries
Kids Chicken Cutlet/French Fries
Kids Riceballs/French Fries
Kids Meatballs/French Fries
Kids Mozzarella Sticks/French Fries
Artichoke Oreganata
artichoke hearts, pecorino, garlic and herbed breadcrumbs topped with white wine and lemon
The Drunken Veggie Sandwich
fried eggplant, ricotta cheese, melted fresh mozzarella, sauteed spinach, vodka sauce.
Bucatini With White Clam Sauce
fresh little neck clams tossed in garlic white wine, lemon and topped with crispy herb breadcrumbs and parsley
Pistachio Crusted Cod
pistachio crusted cod with lemon butter sauce over potato puree and sauteed spinach